Search

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Maruti Swift or Indica Vista What to Buy Confused?

Maruti Swift or Indica Vista or Maruti dZire(desire) ? we were confused with these names from past two weeks as we are planning to buy the new car as we use car pretty much that is almost 60 to 90 kms per day on average we decided to go for diesel car.......

after a some R&D we came to know that both the Vista and Swift shared same engine from fiat both has some similar features in luxury and price tag but some of the important feature indica vista is missing is ABS and Airbags though Indica has little better torque than Swift with same engine under the hood it cannot be judged until it is on road for few months..... though there are many sites claiming indica is better than swift i still remember many of my friends who bought Indica before had tons of problems with it from suspension to engine though i think just changing the engine and change in looks doesnt solve the problem drastically.......

so after comparison of indica vista, maruti swift and maruti dzire(desire) we are planning to go for Maruti Swift Desire(dzire) because of its sporty look, workman ship and after sales services where you can get any part of india below is the comparison of B range cars and Bangalore price tag of maruti dzire(desire)


Maruti Swift Price in Bangalore – Ex Showroom Price*

  • Maruti Suzuki Swift LXi - 4,19,000/- Indian Rupee
  • Maruti Suzuki Swift VXi - 4,42,000/- Indian Rupee
  • Maruti Suzuki Swift ZXi - 5,28,000/- Indian Rupee
  • Maruti Suzuki Swift LDi Diesel - 4,78,000/- Indian Rupee
  • Maruti Suzuki Swift VDi Diesel - 5,14,000/- Indian Rupee

Tata Indica Vista Price in Bangalore

  • Tata Indica Vista Terra TDI Bangalore Price - 3,85,000/-
  • Tata Indica Vista Aqua TDI Bangalore Price- 3,98,000/-
  • Tata Indica Vista Terra Safire Bangalore Price- 3,47,400/-
  • Tata Indica Vista Aqua Safire Bangalore Price - 3,70,500/-
  • Tata Indica Vista Aura Safire Bangalore Price- 3,95,500/-
  • Tata Indica Vista Qudrajet Aqua Bangalore Price - 4,56,600/-
  • Tata Indica Vista Qudrajet Aura Bangalore Price - 4,84,683/-



99 comments:

PRABHOOS said...

I have driven bothe swift VDI & Indica vista quadrijet aura.
Iam listing the comparisons.

LOOKS:
Swift = Sporty looks , interiors cramped , Not much care given in the plastics and mergers in the borders
Indica Vista = Looks like a well refinded indica. Carries lot of authenticity in the design exteriors and interiors. Striking change in the interios include a central console.High quality plastics ,innovative intrument cluster, Mp3 with USB integrated. top lamp is substandard.
DRIVE:

Swift : A drivers car. Smooth gear shift , Better steering grips ( its polyurethane). lacks adjustment in steering wheel.Seat heigh adjustment not possible.Rear is cramped and practically no utility space.The boot is scanty . Overall ride is bumpy on unpaved road( took a deliberate ride to check suspension)and very hard suspension-not expected in this luxury hatchback.
Indica vista quadrihjet- Very comfortable wavy ride in unpaved road ( like a luxury car ! - really unbelievable -needs to be seen to be beleived as it demonstrates it is NOT the OLD indica) .Stering wheel bulky and larger radius althoguh power of steering is good. Gear shift tigter than swift. Excellent visibility even on the rear becaus e of redesigned external mirrrors.
Intrument cluster allows easy visibily. Aura comes fully loaded except Airbags & ABS.

MILEAGE:
SwiftDDSI = 20km/ltr
Indica vista qadrijet ( euro IV)= 25 km /ltr

COMMENTS:

Overall Indica offers better value for money and comfort . Swift has a better resale value .

Anonymous said...

indica vista seems to be good car as compareed to swift. swift is like a bus huge car..best n compact is indica vista..

Anonymous said...

Dzire and sporty looks...
Hey dumb guy ...have u or anyone in your family have seen sports car before? Gosh...indians are so fucking dumb...

Anonymous said...

Ya you are rite we are so dumb that American companies are hiring indians and americans are loosing their jobs :-P

Unknown said...

I think you should go with a top end disel model of indica vista as it is wider & longer than the swift , also you will get a good features as compared to swift in a lesser price.
well i think maruti is well known for there petrol version & tata for there disel version so just go with vista

Anonymous said...

If u want a tougher vehicle, Indica is good; If u want a vehicle with more finesse Swift is good
newport driving school

anjani said...

I AM STILL CONFUSED WHICH ONE IS BETER

Anonymous said...

Definitely if you go buy quality then swift is the best. It has sporty look. So you have a money and you want to have sporty car then go for Swift.

Advantages of Indica are like... it has huge space inside. Comparable build quality, better suspension than swift and good ride quality. In terms of drivability Vista quadrajet scores some more points due to it's tuning to city driving. On the other hand swift has best gear shifts but good gear ratios, but not as Vista. Swift's interior is cramped, and Vista is very spacious and airy. Swift has appealing look. Vista also looks good.

I would suggest Vista if you want to save money and same time you are buying spacious good looking car. Reliability would be same for Vista and Swift.

Buy Swift only if you are passionate about it's look and you have money.

Anonymous said...

I just got a VISTA SAFIRE aura... my sister has a SWIFT VDI already, I am happy with VISTA... i hope VISTA is much better then Swift

Anonymous said...

Dear Anonymous I m planning to buy a vista safire aura like, plz advise me since you have own the car and must have driven considerably on it till date.

anjani said...

FINALLY I GO FOR VISTA THANKS.............................................


ANJANI DWIVEDI(LKO)

Aniruddha said...

At Last.. I and my Wife will go for VISTAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!

Unknown said...

I am confused but I have seen Vista & Swift both. Look wise Swift is Sporty & Vista is tough & Old Indica type. If you have money to buy sporty looks type car then Swift is OK. But other then sporty look swift cannot be as tough as Vista. I will probably go for Vista......

Anonymous said...

I went to check both these(Vista & Swift) cars personally, like everyone mentioned i was shocked to see the transformation from Indica to Indica Vista...

First, The looks are very good and the interiors looks amazing... Its so Spacious compared to any car in this segment.

The front view is equivalent to any Sedan cars.

Mileage,Looks,Space,driveability, ground clearance,etc is excellent. Diesel engine is better for long driving.

Good Fiat Palio gearbox to support which makes it altogether a better car, Just go for it...

Unknown said...

Who the hell said that indica vista gives an avg. of 25 ?
it merely manages 18 on highway.
but there are certain customers of swift diesel who managed to 27.4 km/lt.
two months ago i was also confused which one to buy
but now its crystal clear .............
if u don't want to regret your decision or waste ur money
go for swift disel
it gives 19.5 km/lt on an avg in city and on highway
and cost less than 600 bucks for service per year

Anonymous said...

Thanks, I also will go for a vista

Anonymous said...

dai dzire should'nt be compared with vista its in different league!

Anonymous said...

I bought the Vista - Diesel Aura and feel that
1. The steering is hard compared to Maruti cars
2. The seats are not so comfortable

I have drive a Palio and feel that on the above mentioned perimeters it scores much more than Vista...i dont think TATA motors learnt a lot from the Fiat association

Anonymous said...

I think so, vista is much better bcoz personally i analyse both cars and find that both of cars are good according to their own companies but for the customer's point of view vista is much better than swift and the swift is just a fucking car as compare in price and comfort so if you have alot of money and requires only style then go for swift, but for family,comfort and price bases i prefer vista!! believe me its not like old dumb indica its really fantastic gorgious indica....!!

Remaining decision of your's:-- b coz ur money, ur choice and ur comfort.





BUT!!!!!!!!---- INDICA VISTA IS "THE BEST".

gopal said...

awift is a fucking car, its not fit for...................??????? purpose its too tight......?? understand ?? not fit for.........????purpose

Vista is much better bcoz you can laying in it!! haann??? hahahah!!!!!!

zeeshnav said...

swift looks beautiful sexy and worth -vista looks like old indica with suspensions hard but swift runs smoothly

Anonymous said...

You all guys are talking like bulldung, A guy tells suspension of swift is very good, but it is bulldung Swift suspension works fine only when it goes beyond 130 kmph.

You have good suspension in VISTA but it gets worst when you drive beyond 135 kmph while it is not in same in swift. but speed less than that even palio can't beat Vista's Suspension and ride quality.

And i prefer being a Indian you must prefer to buy Indian car. As Tata car's is always suitable for Indian Roads. Because the car in india going beyond 140 is like nightmare

Anonymous said...

Being accident victim I will suggest that tata cars are far better than Maruti's (Good iron work) Who fool can drive at 140 Km! not even for 30 seconds you can drive even on chandigarh delhi highway. you cannot hold more than 110Km for good thirty to forty seconds . All of us know about indian roads bumps animals what you can expect more is from rickshaw wala which donot indicate but turn more quickly than the world's finest sedans.Its foolish to talk about possesing posh ferr. or Maserati.

Anonymous said...

Style is of course a personal view.There are many who hate the anuran look of Swift.What is perceived sporty may be yucky by another thought. Maruti has the best service network and an excellent goodwill in passenger cars for decades, where Tata is comparatively new entry.But they've come out with loads of improvement and Indica Vista is a proof of that.For Petrol Swift is better but for Diesel, go for Vista Quadrajet ( no Tdi )

satish sharma said...

satish says iam going for indica vista aura i am opting tata car for 3rd time i drove dumb indica very nicely i have completed 2 lakh km in my dumbo car i love my indica and now iam taking vista its great i took the test drive its amazing so indica is the best becoz its indian car and we are proud to be indians. satish new delhi

satish sharma said...

satish; says hey friends i will like to share some of my journey experiences with u me my wife my kids and my indica i took my car to pune by road ,badrinath , gangotri , nagpur , amritsar . it was great driving my indica troublefree so iam happy with my car and i love it

SSS said...

Hey man, If you compare both car I think Indica has better feature value for money than swift:-
Vista Has equivalent engine better gear smothness than swift. more feature like tilt stearing hight adjustment rear fogger 40k cheaper(comparing VDi non abs).
Swift best is Interior finishing is much better than Vista.
40k expending only extra for finishing is not going down the throat easily....
if it is spended that much on vista will give u much better than Swift....18k for aloy wheel 18k for sound proofing.... still 4k left with you....which will give better results than swift.
For ABS lover...sorry to say...EBS+ABS it is useless go to Wikipedia for seeing details...only 2 airbags are not good unless given around passenger means side ways.....see effectiveness see the google search.

Unknown said...

HEY HI GUYS I WANT TO KNOW THAT SHUD I GO FOR VISTA SAFIRE AURA OR TDI AQUA.OR FOR RITZ VXI.PLS ANYONE WHO HAD SAFIRE CAN SUGGEST MEEPLS.........

Anonymous said...

Saffire is no doubt a very good Italian engine with excellently smooth drive and fine milage but that is 1-2 km less than Ritz.But all is compensated by the huge space inside and big price advantage. TDI is a very proven Tata's own engine but you gotta get noise and vibration for the far lesser price than Quadrajet or DDIS engines.

Unknown said...

hi recently i had test drive of both the cars vista as well as swift & swiftdzire, i feel its better to buy vista instead of swift or swift dzire, vista quadrajet(fully loaded) cost u about 5,40000.00 which is VFM, if u want to go for swift u need to pay extra 40 k .
My suggestion about swift is after spending that much money atleast there should be some comfort if it is not there then wht is the use of it. back seat space is ver less(as in maruthi)only front seats are comfortable.
Where as in vista there is lot enough space.moreover waiting period for swift is around 2 months, i decide to book vista.
i decide to book vista,

Anonymous said...

u american fucking..................... u ned to b fuckd.

Anonymous said...

Buy a swift, if u like to drive.
Indica is value for money, but lacks ABS which IMO is critical.
And Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaase dont say a Dzire is SPORTY, its awful.

adarsh said...

those who love sporty driving, go for swift DDIS.,BUT VISTA QUADRAJET is best suited for a family..i own a vista aura quad..and my broter own swift VDi.The basic difference in driving is that, after 60 kmph, swift is much better in attaining high speeds..but for city driving, vista is better as its torque and speed range is higher in 2nt and 3rd gear

Nishith said...

I just bought Aura Safire and i'm already in love with this car. It's value for money because it comes with huge real estate and features for lesser money. It may not be as sporty as others in the same or slightly higer class but it surely is the most comfortable car in it's segment. Both Interior & Exterior are good. It gives you a feel of driving a bigger sedan from inside. You may buy a swift if you mostly drive alone however if you are buying it for your family then buy Vista.

AnooplalJayalal said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
AnooplalJayalal said...

after a long search and comparisons am decided to buy Vista Aura, bcoz its stylish interiors and smart look and performance, may be the performance of swift is better ,but its interior is very poor, and small leg space for back seats. So comparatively VISTA will be the best and economical, its cost upto 1 lakh lesser than swift

Unknown said...

vista safire aura is the best than swift..n now a days swift is very common.i think vista has got more heavy looks than swift..so blindly buy a vista safire aura..and the best dashing n attractive color is its off white color!!damn gooood!!i have it

Anonymous said...

Finally....I ve decided to go for Vista Aqua (Quadrajet).

Attractions over Swift

Initial Pricing
Space
Improved looks
Cheaper spare parts
finally but important Fiat built engine and gear box.

Anonymous said...

QUALITY WISE MARUTI IS BEST BUT
SWIFT DRIVING = BULLOCK CART
ESPECIALLY BACK SEAT
SUSPENSION VERY BAD
VISTA ONE OF THE BEST SUSPENSION
I AM GOING TO SELL MY NEW SWIFT
AND THINK TO BUY VISTA
mathew,9495085330

Unknown said...

well according to me indica vistaaaaaa is the best for long route driving and and gives you an easy romantic and comfortable driving who cares about maruti's shit cars n they are totally dumbs who like maruti cars

Anonymous said...

vjo saare lun te bnde nu pta ni lgda swift laiye ja vista

Anonymous said...

hi vista is superb driving pleasure, high pick up,best suspension but average finishing (body),poor average.It"s 50:50 tie up

phanibioinfo said...

me too confused but i am decided to take indica

Anonymous said...

I have driven both vehicles. Go for indica vista with quadrajet.

1. Price of indica vista top end aura costs 5.5 lakhs on road. But price of swift LDI costs you 5.54 lakhs. What indica vista aura has on top of swift LDI is power windows + stero + 4 speakers + rear wiper + body colored mirror and door handles + 60:40 rear seat folding

2. Sit in the back seat of indica vista when someone is driving. After that sit in the swift back seat. You will definitely reject Swift.

3. Initial pickup of quadrajet engine is superb compared to any of its segments. You don't feel like you are driving a diesel engine car. Palio swift even puto lacks at this point of pickup.

4. Beware and dont go for vista TDI engine, its tata's engine and its initial pickup is very less. Its good for highway driving. Also the engine noise is high compared to quadrajet.

5. Parts of indica vista are cheap compared to swift and mileage of indica vista is 2 KM more than swift.

Anonymous said...

Hi Folks,

Vista ( Fully Loaded - AURA ) Vs Swift VDI :

Vista :
MP3 with USB port + 4 Speakers, Driver Seat adjustment, Steering TILT, Fog lights, Rear glass De-mister, Wiper, Excellent Dash board / interior, Fiat Engine etc.,
Swift ( VDI ) :
None of the above.

Vista :
To compromise with the look same as old Indica
Swift :
Many are saying , Sporty look.. If yes.. Let me say the same.

Vista :
Rear seat ( 60 / 40 ) - You can fold the back seat to accomodate your luggage and comfort seating for rear side seaters.
Swift :
No such option , Samll rear seat & uncomfortable for people sitting in rear - Leg spacing.

Vista :Ex Show room Price ( Chennai ) : 475000INR aprox.

Swift : Ex show room Price ( Chennai ) 503944 INR aprox.

So, Its better to go & buy TATA VISTA.
Be Indian, Buy Indian ( Which is the best always )

- Prakaash

swiftlover said...

swift is the top among diesel the hatchback models punto,fabia,i2... fucking vista not even in competition.. swift s thousand times better than vista... it may looks better at starting price , interior, suspension,,...bt those will not stay longer.. u may have to spend half of ur salary in workshop,,,, maruti swift is named for its less maintanence, good mileage, worthy, withstand forever.......

Anonymous said...

look at the engine, gearbox , maintanence, mileage... swift is the top class car... how dare u compare angel swift with fucking indica?...

Anonymous said...

Too many cowards (Anonymous said)on this page writing comments. People when they find their name can be hidden use abusive words. if you have guts.. write you name and put the comment.
/ Sangodkar (Goa, India)

Anonymous said...

bakwash

Anonymous said...

Lun lo saleyo.

Anonymous said...

i have test driven swift vdi and the indica vista aura abs...some points i have observed.

swift
ups:
sporty
excellent handling
great gear shift
downs:
black drab interiors
rear leg space
hard suspension

vista
overall a nice package with all the extra features + abs now
blue tooth feature
great ride quality...better than swift any day
good interiors
airy cabin
rear 60:40 split
acres of rear leg room
great practicality

downs:
tatas after sales service
cheap quality plastics (infact if u see the door handles and twist them a bit they seems that they wud come out)
tatas small niggling issues...i have read in other forums that owners had a lot of nitty gritty issues with the lights ac's n all

Verdict:-
i would recommend an indica vista for the practical buyer...has a decent average as well vista quad has an average of 15 city and 18-19 highway which is decent.
swift is for the more sporty guy...one who likes a sporty good handled car but is ok to compromise on the features and space.

Hondapartx said...

Maruti Swift and Tata Indica Vista both are same car, but Maruti Swift some better of than Indica Vista,Swift have some sporty car than of Indica,

We are provide high quality Parts,Quality Certificate/Engine, And Honda Parts Our site offers online access to multiple automotive part stores.


Used Honda parts

Unknown said...

dear all pls do not purchese tata any cars like indica, indica vista, indigo, tata product not give ful satishfaction

SathyaNarayanan said...

I Have Indica vista qutrajet aura and my bro has swift (diesel). I drive both vehicles almost equally, Sift has sporty looks... Other than that in comfort, inner leg space, driving, mileage, and safety vista is the best, 5 ppl weighing near 80kgs can sit in vista without touching each other this is not possible in SWIFT.. after sales in service also TATA is doing very good job. clear win is for VISTA

karTic RaJu said...

iam totally confused 2 buy either VISTA r SWIFT...,,,because in my view SWIFT looks like a hightech sports model vehicle than VISTA.....and cuming 2 VISTA which gives more milaege than SWIFT............ and also cost less than SWIFT.....
...........................................................................KARTIC...

Unknown said...

look guyz if u'r payin money u ll surely get satisfaction in both the cars... so juz dun waste ur time thinkin what to buy.... if u don have prob with money go for swift or if any prob than go to vista..both are good

Unknown said...

It is better to go for Tata VISTA. Where as for Maruti they only claim that the after sales service.(it probably has more problems,, hence frequent visit for servie??) there is nothing great about it. Morover diesel engihe used in both the cars are from thrid party. There is no question of innovation from maruti.

Unknown said...

I am also confused for Maruti Swift & Tata Indica Vista for last 2 months

Unknown said...

pls advice for local driving 60-90 kms per/day for marketing Tata Indica Vista or Maruti Swift VDI

Unknown said...

tata company is not good because they made flop cars and maintainance cost of indica is too much that we now very well i think india's most no of people like only maruti swift

Unknown said...

siwft pick up is good compared to vista bcoz it weight less than vista,rest all vista is the winner especially in the back seat comfort

Unknown said...

Indica vista is good but the service charges are too high. Service centers are charging like anything. Maruthi service centers are better than tata.

nitin said...

indica vista is best car in this segment

Unknown said...

Which would be better for once in week use? say 100Km per week and 1 long drive in 3 months?

Is Tata service cost too high?

Anonymous said...

tata vista vs maruti swift

vista give feels like u r sitting in a big car
i bet u never like to come out from the car..
vista has a label of taxi
where as maruti swift is a brand status..

the tacho meter is not present infront of the drivers seat..
its in the middle


any one ask tata y it is in the middle.
.
its totally spoiling the look of vista

Anonymous said...

It is quite eveident you all have been paid by Tata motors to give these crap suggestions about swift. Don't even feel like talking to all you bunch of LOOSERS coz their is no point as you will still lick indica's ass. Remember Swift is a world and what ever you say or write the sales volume always speak the best.

Anonymous said...

INDICA VISTA BETTER THAN SWIFT

Anonymous said...

MILEAGE:
SwiftDDSI = 20km/ltr
Indica vista = 27 km /ltr

Anonymous said...

hi to all those anonymous people,
car is for driving not for fucking dudes, hope u understand. if u want to fuck, only cars exhaust would be sufficient, why u need a car. talk abt the performances of the vehicles not to fuck them.
presently VISTA has VFM over any other cars.

Anonymous said...

@above
Road cars = comfort, formula cars = peformance...

whts the use of peformance when u dont have comfort... wanna sit cock tight while driving :P

Anonymous said...

@above
nice 1..

Anonymous said...

Proud owner of Vista. Swift is nothing but for teenage. Comparatively Cheap than Swift in cost & spares

geog said...

Currently i am having Maruti WagonR. I am in a plan to sell it and buy a new diesel car. I will be having 110 km daily driving to & fro office. So Fuel efficency is my first concern. Then comes maintenance. Also i need to take 3 lakh loan for buying a new car. I am inclined towards Indica Vista Quadrajet Terra (least investment). Kindly put your suggestions

Anonymous said...

The above all messages I read, Still I am confused in both (Vista & Swift), which one is better than the other.

Anonymous said...

hello folks i bought my new vista aura qudra smooth driving n cool lukin
i luv mw vista!!!!

Anonymous said...

i have a swift VDI (purchase date 15 Dec 2010), i am getting lots of issue in this car....

1) mileage 10-11 In City, and 15 on High way
2) to much maintenance (i was using Maruti 800, which maintenance cost was nill, based on that i purchase maruti suzuki swift VDI.) but its maintenance cost is too much....even more then i10 (my brother has i10)

3) third class build quality and no advance feature. tooo costly as compare to other

now, maruti is only running on goodwill, even ritz and estilo is not good.

Anonymous said...

INDICA VISTA is the BEST

sachin dev said...

hey frnz.. dont get too confused. both the cars are best in thr way.
comparing vista quad aura ABS and swift vdi ABS driveability is same for both the cars and mileage is same..22kmpl. but taking into consideration of additional features vista has bluetooth enabled music system with 440w speakers, Tilt steering wheel, rear glass defogger, and interior quality of plastics is better and with all these qualities it comes 60000 cheaper then swift.. safety on collision is great in vista. its value for money car with a proud Indian tag. just go with vista frnzzzzzzzzz........

Anonymous said...

Here are some of comparison facts:

Exterior view: Swift looks better than Vista

Interior: Vista has better and pleasent interior look than Swift, is having all black from inside

Space: Vista has a good space than Swift

Comfort: Excelt comfort with vista. Swift is having very poor comfort for the back seat. people. Low rear leg space.

Suspension: Vista offers better suspension than Swift on roads.

Gear Shifting: Swifts offer smoother gear shifting than vista.

After sales service: As usual TATA when will learn to satisfy their customers with the after sales service. Maruti has better after slaes service support.

For long drive: Vista stands best than swift with much better driving, seating comfort.

Millage: @ same for both

VFM: Vista is always have VFM than Swift.

Suggestion: Go for Vista

Vishal, Pune

Santhosh said...

Same confussions have been with me for a months time & finally felt Indiaca Vista is good, with comfortable rear space & Fiat Engine 90 s & Fiat gear box of 2007 model awarded engine, where as swift with 2004 model engine & suzuki gear box.
Also recommending Vista for the following reasons, front seat height & back adjustments, rear seat with 60:40 partitions & good rear space with bluetooth USB inbuilt audio system & ABS.
Indica Vista superbbbb.....

Santhosh

Anonymous said...

should i wait to see the launch of new swift diesel is it worth waiting as it has long booking or i should go for indica vista quadrajet aura ABS.
kindly suggest.

Anonymous said...

Why are the people so confused,both the cars share the same engine and gear box from fiat so the performance would be almost same. And if there is a slight increase in the performance of swift then it is due to its light kerb weight. And indica being more spacious and tougher would be relaible in the long run. And commenting about the sporty look,if a car doesn't have a powerful or high rev engine then why looks.

Anonymous said...

I have bought a Vista Aura recently it is very comfortable also when u compare with swift , Vista is very spacious , interior is attractive than Swift, even cost effective and additional features for lesser price than swift. Swift is very stylish and Vista is not... Those who are concern about style go for Swift, those who are concern about family comfortablity and economy go for Vista........ Thanks S.Navaz

Geo said...

I have purchased Vista Quadrajet Terra (Least Investment) and I have done 3800 kms upto now. I am travelling 110 kms to and fro office a day and my travel is almostly thru NH. When I checked mileage(Full Tsnk to Full tank) twice, I got 24.5 and 23.7. This is without A/C and a steady speed of 60-70 in NH. I am very much satisfied with the car upto now. Following are the key points influenced me for finalizing vista from swift

1. Waiting Period

swift : 6-8 months
Vista : 2 weeks max

2. Body Weight

Vista weighs 100 Kgs more than swift. I believe this measure a saftey advantage for Vista in case of any collision, if happens.

3. Interior

Swift : Cheap plastics
Vista : Now comes only as Refresh model, which is far better.

4. Space

Swift : 3 people can tightly fit in back seat with cramped leg space
Vista : 4 people can sit relaxed with lavish leg space.

5. Driving Comfort

Swift : I think here swift scores more with good instant pickup.
Vista : Not bad, but Swift scores more

6. Gear Shift

Swift : Swift scores more
Vista : Better than its precedors

7: Handling

Swift : Electronic steering.Light but will not feel confidence.
Vista : Hydraulic . Will feel confidence.

8: Perfection

Swift : It looks more perfect
Vista : Dont think for perfections. Not suitable for any perfectionists.

9: Service

Swift: Good service backup. They will follup up you and will get serviced.
Vista: If you want service, you must go and get it done. (Even the delivery people didnt told me about extended warranty yet. I heard from my friend and asked them for that.)

10. Cost

Vista base model is atleast 30-40 K less than Swift. New swift model price hearing will be 18 K addition to old swift model.


------------
Overall
------------
Both vehicle uses Fiat Multijet technology. So no need to worry about engine and mileage.

Perfectionists dont go for Vista, else, Vista is the best. Moreover, TATA is an indian product, what is the problem in using an Indian product which is good and cheap. Moreover, we can use an indian product and be a proud indian.

Anonymous said...

TATA INDICA VIST IS THE BEST

Anonymous said...

kindly tell us about BOOTSPACE of SWIFTandVISTA

arvind jondhale said...

which is the best car? Swift or tata indica vista?

Anonymous said...

indica has poor suspension it get dis mental in 2-3 years and maintenance cost is too much as comared to swift and after sale is too poor in indica . after 3-5 year engine sound in indica is like a tractor but in swift its silent through out life

ashish said...

no sir, my friend has done 100000 km with his 2009 model of indica vista quadrajet aura. no problem with engine sound and body. indica is still running like new. go for indica vista. be an indian

Anonymous said...

Indica Vista is a great car...it gives the essence of Sedan,comfortable and is economical too!!

rolwyn johann said...

tata indica vista quadrajet is better than swift,vw polo,hyundai i10,and any other hatchbacks around 5 lacs price.

Anonymous said...

we have to accept now that maruti is not as better like before... i buy tata again.. vista vx sedan class with quadrajet engine.. before buying car just take a test drive.... u got more reasons to buy an tata care.... very good suspension....

why tata indica is in taxi?? cause it is economical and have good engine life...

my friend have maruti desire... he promise to never buy maruti again.. cause soo much problems..

indica vista comes with 2 years or 75000 km warranty... extended warranty is 4 years or 150000 km... i think Rs. 5100/- for extended warranty of 150000 km is very very big thing in itself...

if maruti is good and better then indica then why not give same warranty with same engine??


tata is reliable then maruti.... and soon become number 1 in small cars segments too..

Anonymous said...

indica vista new is best,i have 2 vista tdi.love both of them,but now want sell one 09890608060.khan

Anonymous said...

Friends, I have purchased the new Tata Indica eV2 LS model. Vista has German engine and Indica and Indigo have the engines made by Tata. Indica (CR4 Quadrajet engine) as well as Indica Vista, both are much better than Swift. Won't say that Swift is a bad car, but it's external looks are like old (mendak type) car. Moreover, people sitting inside a Swift are like packed. While driving Indica eV2 or Indica Vista is really confortable. Make your own decision........

Prasad S said...

Indica Vista is Best,Becouse i am going to buy the same

Archna Singh said...

can anybody suggest which car is best in diesel

Archna Singh said...

can anybody suggest which car is best in diesel

Anonymous said...

MARUTHI TAKIN ADVANTAGE OF CUSTOMER AND HIKING PRISE .............CHANGE D TREND GO FOR VISTA

Unknown said...

To add to the comfort the new tata indica vista has adjustable steering along with adjustable seats to give utmost comfort to the driver. The seating has a lumbar support. There is also ample room for luggage at the rear with the seats folded.

Post a Comment

Other Interesting Articles



Related Article Widget by Yogith

Search Powered by Google